🔪 In November 2006, Athens Township, Pennsylvania was shaken by the shocking murders of David and Carol Keeffe. David, a respected lawyer, and his wife Carol were found shot to death in the garage of their home near Sayre. Investigators uncovered that the motive stemmed from a bitter property dispute within the family. Years later, in December 2010, Carol’s cousin, John DeSisti, was arrested and charged with their murders. Prosecutors revealed how resentment over land ownership escalated into d